- Research Article
- Open Access
- Published:

# An Implicit Extragradient Method for Hierarchical Variational Inequalities

*Fixed Point Theory and Applications*
**volume 2011**, Article number: 697248 (2011)

## Abstract

As a well-known numerical method, the extragradient method solves numerically the variational inequality of finding such that , for all . In this paper, we devote to solve the following hierarchical variational inequality Find such that , for all . We first suggest and analyze an implicit extragradient method for solving the hierarchical variational inequality . It is shown that the net defined by the suggested implicit extragradient method converges strongly to the unique solution of in Hilbert spaces. As a special case, we obtain the minimum norm solution of the variational inequality .

## 1. Introduction

The variational inequality problem is to find such that

The set of solutions of the variational inequality problem is denoted by . It is well known that the variational inequality theory has emerged as an important tool in studying a wide class of obstacle, unilateral, and equilibrium problems; which arise in several branches of pure and applied sciences in a unified and general framework. Several numerical methods have been developed for solving variational inequalities and related optimization problems, see [1–24] and the references therein. In particular, Korpelevich's extragradient method which was introduced by Korpelevič [4] in 1976 generates a sequence via the recursion

where is the metric projection from onto , is a monotone operator, and is a constant. Korpelevich [4] proved that the sequence converges strongly to a solution of . Note that the setting of the space is Euclid space .

Recently, hierarchical fixed point problems and hierarchical minimization problems have attracted many authors' attention due to their link with some convex programming problems. See [25–32]. Motivated and inspired by these results in the literature, in this paper we are devoted to solve the following hierarchical variational inequality :

For this purpose, in this paper, we first suggest and analyze an implicit extragradient method. It is shown that the net defined by this implicit extragradient method converges strongly to the unique solution of in Hilbert spaces. As a special case, we obtain the minimum norm solution of the variational inequality .

## 2. Preliminaries

Let be a real Hilbert space with inner product and norm , and let be a closed convex subset of . Recall that a mapping is called -inverse strongly monotone if there exists a positive real number such that

A mapping is said to be -contraction if there exists a constant such that

It is well known that, for any , there exists a unique such that

We denote by , where is called the *metric projection* of onto . The metric projection of onto has the following basic properties:

(i) for all ;

(ii) for every ;

(iii) for all , ;

(iv) for all , .

Such properties of will be crucial in the proof of our main results. Let be a monotone mapping of into . In the context of the variational inequality problem, it is easy to see from property (iii) that

We need the following lemmas for proving our main result.

Lemma 2.1 (see [13]).

Let be a nonempty closed convex subset of a real Hilbert space . Let the mapping be -inverse strongly monotone, and let be a constant. Then, one has

In particular, if , then is nonexpansive.

Lemma 2.2 (see [32]).

Let be a nonempty closed convex subset of a real Hilbert space . Assume that the mapping is monotone and weakly continuous along segments, that is, weakly as . Then, the variational inequality

is equivalent to the dual variational inequality

## 3. Main Result

In this section, we will introduce our implicit extragradient algorithm and show its strong convergence to the unique solution of .

Algorithm 1.

*Let*
*be a closed convex subset of a real Hilbert space*
*. Let*
*be an*
*-inverse strongly monotone mapping. Let*
*be a (nonself) contraction with coefficient*
*. For any*
*, define a net*
*as follows:*

where is a constant.

Note the fact that is a possible nonself mapping. Hence, if we take , then (3.1) reduces to

Remark 3.1.

We notice that the net defined by (3.1) is well defined. In fact, we can define a self-mapping as follows:

From Lemma 2.1, we know that if , the mapping is nonexpansive.

For any , we have

This shows that the mapping is a contraction. By Banach contractive mapping principle, we immediately deduce that the net (3.1) is well defined.

Theorem 3.2.

Suppose the solution set of is nonempty. Then the net generated by the implicit extragradient method (3.1) converges in norm, as , to the unique solution of the hierarchical variational inequality . In particular, if one takes that , then the net defined by (3.2) converges in norm, as , to the minimum-norm solution of the variational inequality .

Proof.

Take that . Since , using the relation (2.4), we have . In particular, if we take , we obtain

From (3.1), we have

Noting that is nonexpansive, thus,

That is,

Therefore, is bounded and so are , . Since is -inverse strongly monotone, it is -Lipschitz continuous. Consequently, and are also bounded.

From (3.6),(2.5), and the convexity of the norm, we deduce

Therefore, we have

Hence

By the property (ii) of the metric projection , we have

where is some appropriate constant. It follows that

and hence (by (3.7))

which implies that

Since , we derive

Next, we show that the net is relatively norm-compact as . Assume that is such that as . Put and .

By the property (ii) of metric projection , we have

Hence

Therefore,

In particular,

Since is bounded, without loss of generality, we may assume that converges weakly to a point . Since , we have . Hence, also converges weakly to the same point .

Next we show that . We define a mapping by

Then is maximal monotone (see [33]). Let . Since and , we have . On the other hand, from , we have

that is,

Therefore, we have

Noting that , , and is Lipschitz continuous, we obtain . Since is maximal monotone, we have and hence .

Therefore we can substitute for in (3.20) to get

Consequently, the weak convergence of and to actually implies that strongly. This has proved the relative norm-compactness of the net as .

Now we return to (3.20) and take the limit as to get

In particular, solves the following VI

or the equivalent dual VI (see Lemma 2.2)

Therefore, . That is, is the unique solution in of the contraction . Clearly this is sufficient to conclude that the entire net converges in norm to as .

Finally, if we take that , then VI (3.28) is reduced to

Equivalently,

This clearly implies that

Therefore, is the minimum-norm solution of .This completes the proof.

Remark 3.3.

## References

- 1.
Stampacchia G:

**Formes bilinéaires coercitives sur les ensembles convexes.***Comptes rendus de I'Academie des. Sciences*1964,**258:**4413–4416. - 2.
Lions J-L, Stampacchia G:

**Variational inequalities.***Communications on Pure and Applied Mathematics*1967,**20:**493–519. 10.1002/cpa.3160200302 - 3.
Liu F, Nashed MZ:

**Regularization of nonlinear ill-posed variational inequalities and convergence rates.***Set-Valued Analysis*1998,**6**(4):313–344. 10.1023/A:1008643727926 - 4.
Korpelevič GM:

**An extragradient method for finding saddle points and for other problems.***Èkonomika i Matematicheskie Metody*1976,**12**(4):747–756. - 5.
Glowinski R:

*Numerical Methods for Nonlinear Variational Problems, Springer Series in Computational Physics*. Springer, New York, NY, USA; 1984:xv+493. - 6.
Iusem AN, Svaiter BF:

**A variant of Korpelevich's method for variational inequalities with a new search strategy.***Optimization*1997,**42**(4):309–321. 10.1080/02331939708844365 - 7.
Khobotov EN:

**Modification of the extra-gradient method for solving variational inequalities and certain optimization problems.***USSR Computational Mathematics and Mathematical Physics*1989,**27**(5):120–127. - 8.
Solodov MV, Svaiter BF:

**A new projection method for variational inequality problems.***SIAM Journal on Control and Optimization*1999,**37**(3):765–776. 10.1137/S0363012997317475 - 9.
Aslam Noor M:

**Some developments in general variational inequalities.***Applied Mathematics and Computation*2004,**152**(1):199–277. 10.1016/S0096-3003(03)00558-7 - 10.
Yao Y, Yao J-C:

**On modified iterative method for nonexpansive mappings and monotone mappings.***Applied Mathematics and Computation*2007,**186**(2):1551–1558. 10.1016/j.amc.2006.08.062 - 11.
Censor Y, Gibali A, Reich S:

**Two extensions of Korpelevich's extragradient method for solving the variational inequality problem in Euclidean space.**2010. - 12.
Censor Y, Gibali A, Reich S:

**The subgradient extragradient method for solving variational inequalities in Hilbert space.***Journal of Optimization Theory and Applications*. In press - 13.
Takahashi W, Toyoda M:

**Weak convergence theorems for nonexpansive mappings and monotone mappings.***Journal of Optimization Theory and Applications*2003,**118**(2):417–428. 10.1023/A:1025407607560 - 14.
Yao Y, Liou YC, Marino G:

**Strong convergence of two iterative algorithms for nonexpansive mappings in Hilbert spaces.***Fixed Point Theory and Applications*2009,**2009:**-7. - 15.
Yao Y, Liou Y-C, Wu Y-J:

**An extragradient method for mixed equilibrium problems and fixed point problems.***Fixed Point Theory and Applications*2009,**2009:**-15. - 16.
Yao Y, Liou Y-C, Yao J-C:

**A new hybrid iterative algorithm for fixed-point problems, variational inequality problems, and mixed equilibrium problems.***Fixed Point Theory and Applications*2008,**2008:**-15. - 17.
Yao Y, Liou Y-C, Yao J-C:

**Convergence theorem for equilibrium problems and fixed point problems of infinite family of nonexpansive mappings.***Fixed Point Theory and Applications*2007,**2007:**-12. - 18.
Yao Y, Liou Y-C, Yao J-C:

**An extragradient method for fixed point problems and variational inequality problems.***Journal of Inequalities and Applications*2007,**2007:**-12. - 19.
Wang S, Marino G, Wang F:

**Strong convergence theorems for a generalized equilibrium problem with a relaxed monotone mapping and a countable family of nonexpansive mappings in a Hilbert space.***Fixed Point Theory and Applications*2010,**2010:**-22. - 20.
Cianciaruso F, Marino G, Muglia L, Yao Y:

**A hybrid projection algorithm for finding solutions of mixed equilibrium problem and variational inequality problem.***Fixed Point Theory and Applications*2010,**2010:**-19. - 21.
Cianciaruso F, Marino G, Muglia L, Yao Y:

**On a two-step algorithm for hierarchical fixed point problems and variational inequalities.***Journal of Inequalities and Applications*2009,**2009:**-13. - 22.
Peng J-W, Wu S-Y, Yao J-C:

**A new iterative method for finding common solutions of a system of equilibrium problems, fixed-point problems, and variational inequalities.***Abstract and Applied Analysis*2010,**2010:**-27. - 23.
Zeng L-C, Ansari QH, Shyu DS, Yao J-C:

**Strong and weak convergence theorems for common solutions of generalized equilibrium problems and zeros of maximal monotone operators.***Fixed Point Theory and Applications*2010,**2010:**-33. - 24.
Zeng L-C, Kum S, Yao J-C:

**Algorithm for solving a generalized mixed equilibrium problem with perturbation in a Banach space.***Fixed Point Theory and Applications*2010,**2010:**22. - 25.
Moudafi A, Maingé P-E:

**Towards viscosity approximations of hierarchical fixed-point problems.***Fixed Point Theory and Applications*2006,**2006:**10. - 26.
Xu H-K:

**Viscosity method for hierarchical fixed point approach to variational inequalities.***Taiwanese Journal of Mathematics*2010,**14**(2):463–478. - 27.
Cianciaruso F, Colao V, Muglia L, Xu H-K:

**On an implicit hierarchical fixed point approach to variational inequalities.***Bulletin of the Australian Mathematical Society*2009,**80**(1):117–124. 10.1017/S0004972709000082 - 28.
Maingé P-E, Moudafi A:

**Strong convergence of an iterative method for hierarchical fixed-point problems.***Pacific Journal of Optimization*2007,**3**(3):529–538. - 29.
Moudafi A:

**Krasnoselski-Mann iteration for hierarchical fixed-point problems.***Inverse Problems*2007,**23**(4):1635–1640. 10.1088/0266-5611/23/4/015 - 30.
Yao Y, Liou Y-C:

**Weak and strong convergence of Krasnoselski-Mann iteration for hierarchical fixed point problems.***Inverse Problems*2008,**24**(1):8. - 31.
Marino G, Colao V, Muglia L, Yao Y:

**Krasnoselski-Mann iteration for hierarchical fixed points and equilibrium problem.***Bulletin of the Australian Mathematical Society*2009,**79**(2):187–200. 10.1017/S000497270800107X - 32.
Lu X, Xu H-K, Yin X:

**Hybrid methods for a class of monotone variational inequalities.***Nonlinear Analysis: Theory, Methods & Applications*2009,**71**(3–4):1032–1041. 10.1016/j.na.2008.11.067 - 33.
Rockafellar RT:

**Monotone operators and the proximal point algorithm.***SIAM Journal on Control and Optimization*1976,**14**(5):877–898. 10.1137/0314056 - 34.
Sabharwal A, Potter LC:

**Convexly constrained linear inverse problems: iterative least-squares and regularization.***IEEE Transactions on Signal Processing*1998,**46**(9):2345–2352. 10.1109/78.709518 - 35.
Cui Y-L, Liu X:

**Notes on Browder's and Halpern's methods for nonexpansive mappings.***Fixed Point Theory*2009,**10**(1):89–98. - 36.
Liu X, Cui Y:

**The common minimal-norm fixed point of a finite family of nonexpansive mappings.***Nonlinear Analysis: Theory, Methods & Applications*2010,**73**(1):76–83. 10.1016/j.na.2010.02.041 - 37.
Yao Y, Chen R, Xu H-K:

**Schemes for finding minimum-norm solutions of variational inequalities.***Nonlinear Analysis: Theory, Methods & Applications*2010,**72**(7–8):3447–3456. 10.1016/j.na.2009.12.029 - 38.
Yao Y, Xu HK:

**Iterative methods for finding minimum-norm fixed points of nonexpansive mappings with applications.***Optimization*. In press

## Acknowledgments

The authors thank the referees for their comments and suggestions which improved the presentation of this paper. The first author was supported in part by Colleges and Universities, Science and Technology Development Foundation (20091003) of Tianjin and NSFC 11071279. The second author was supported in part by NSC 99-2221-E-230-006

## Author information

## Rights and permissions

**Open Access** This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 International License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

## About this article

### Cite this article

Yao, Y., Liou, Y. An Implicit Extragradient Method for Hierarchical Variational Inequalities.
*Fixed Point Theory Appl* **2011, **697248 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1155/2011/697248

Received:

Accepted:

Published:

### Keywords

- Variational Inequality
- Maximal Monotone
- Real Hilbert Space
- Variational Inequality Problem
- Nonempty Closed Convex Subset